On November 10th, 2020, newly minted New York Mets owner Steve Cohen declared that if the club didn’t win a World Series title in three to five years, it would be “disappointing.” Well, we are now entering year six of the Cohen era, with no championship trophy in sight. In fact, they’ve only made the playoffs twice in that span. They notably missed the dance entirely last year (after a superb and unexpected 2024 season), in embarrassing fashion. How will the Mets fare in 2026 with a brand new core? Let’s take a look:
2025 Season-In-Review
Record: 83-79, 2nd Place in NL East
Team MVP: OF Juan Soto
Team Cy Young: RHP Edwin Díaz
The 2025 Mets were a tale of two teams. On June 12th, they were 45-24, which was the best record in baseball. They went 38-55 the rest of the season, the fifth worst mark in the sport and were eliminated from playoff contention on the last day of the season at the hands of the Miami Marlins.
Side note, if I had a nickel for how many times the Marlins have knocked the Mets out of the playoffs on the final day of the season following a devastating collapse, I’d have three nickels. That’s not really a lot, but it’s kind of weird that has happened THREE times in my lifetime.
Anyway, let’s start with the good. Francisco Lindor and Soto were their usual incredible selves, as both players joined the 30-30 club. Pete Alonso and Díaz had great bounce back years. Brett Baty was a pleasant surprise. Francisco Alvarez was awesome in the second half. Brandon Nimmo and Jeff McNeil were productive. Clay Holmes rocked a 114 ERA+ in his first year as a starter in the big leagues. The good pretty much stops there.
Pitching is where the team mainly faltered. David Peterson was an All-Star and posted a 3.06 ERA in the first half, before running out of gas down the stretch. Kodai Senga did much of the same, as he never recovered from a hamstring injury that occurred in June and was eventually demoted to Triple-A in September. Frankie Montas was atrocious. Sean Manaea took a major step back from his excellent 2024 second half. Ryne Stanek somehow lasted a full season in the bullpen, despite a 5.30 ERA. Nolan McLean did his best to right the ship, but it was too far gone by the time he debuted.
Let me put it into perspective for you. The Mets had a 60-game stretch in which Peterson was the only starter to eclipse six innings of work in a game. That hadn’t happened since 1901. They also set an MLB record for most pitchers used in a season with 46. That isn’t good.
It didn’t help that the trade deadline “reinforcements” were horrific. Flamethrower Ryan Helsley was unbelievably bad after being acquired from the St. Louis Cardinals. His 7.20 ERA was easily the worst of his career. Cedric Mullins was nabbed from the Baltimore Orioles to shore up center field. He promptly registered a .565 OPS.
Watching the 2025 Mets felt like living the same day over and over again. It seemed like each game was indistinguishable from the one before it. The offense would do enough, then pack up shop for the night. The starter wouldn’t last five innings. The bullpen would blow the lead. Wash. Rinse. Repeat.
Needless to say, the 2025 Mets were an absolute disaster. There is no good reason for a team with that payroll to miss the playoffs, but they quite frankly deserved it. This was a wake-up call.
Offseason Review
Key losses from 2025: 1B Pete Alonso, OF Brandon Nimmo, RHP Edwin Díaz, UTIL Jeff McNeil, RHP Tyler Rogers, RHP Griffin Canning, OF/DH Starling Marte, UTIL Luisangel Acuña, RHP Ryan Helsley, LHP Gregory Soto, OF Cedric Mullins, RHP Brandon Sproat
Notable Free Agent Additions: 3B Bo Bichette (3/$126M, opt-outs after 1st and 2nd years), RHP Devin Williams ($3/51M), RHP Luke Weaver (2/$22M), 1B/DH Jorge Polanco (2/$40M), RHP Luis García (1/$1.75M), OF Mike Tauchman (minor league deal), OF/1B MJ Melendez (1/$1.5M)
Notable Trades:
- Received RHP Freddy Peralta and RHP Tobias Myers from the Milwaukee Brewers for SS/OFJett Williams (minors) and RHP Brandon Sproat
- Received OF Luis Robert Jr. from the Chicago White Sox for UTIL Luisangel Acuña and RHP Truman Pauley (minors)
- Received 2B Marcus Semien from the Texas Rangers for OF Brandon Nimmo
- Received RHP Yordan Rodriguez (minors) from the Athletics for UTIL Jeff McNeil
President of baseball operations David Stearns and Cohen oversaw an absolute rollercoaster of an offseason. First, there was the controversial trade of the fan favorite Nimmo to the Rangers for the aging and expensive Semien. Semien, despite a below average OPS+ of 97 in 2025, will bolster the defense up the middle. This move set the tone for what was to come next.
At the Winter Meetings in Orlando, New York received an onslaught of bad news. First, Díaz (coming off an elite 1.63 ERA in 2025) signed with the reigning champion Los Angeles Dodgers. This came after the Mets signed Williams (coming off a 4.79 ERA, easily the worst of his career) to a lucrative deal, which reportedly irked Díaz.
The very next day, Alonso, the club’s longtime slugger and 2024 postseason hero, inked a five-year, $155 million dollar deal with the Orioles. Later in December, McNeil, a former batting champ, was shipped off to the A’s. Just like that, “Sugar,” the “Squirrel,” and the “Polar Bear” were gone.
Luckily for the Mets (and to the surprise of reactionary fans), the season doesn’t start in December. There was still plenty of time to build a competitive roster, and they certainly made the most of it. Polanco was quickly brought in to replace Alonso at first, despite only playing one career game at the position. In 2025, Polanco remarkably cut his strike out rate in half (15.6% compared to 29.2% in 2024).
The big ticket signing for the Mets was for Bichette to play third base, a deal that came off the heels of Kyle Tucker’s move to the Dodgers. While he will likely provide questionable defense, Bo knows how to drive in runs. Both him and Polanco have the “clutch” gene and make consistent contact, indicating that New York wanted to improve in those areas in 2026. The Mets famously were 0-70 when trailing after eight innings in 2025, so those qualities should help in that regard.
Stearns and Co. were active in the trade market, as well. They bought low on Robert. Once considered to be the Cuban Mike Trout, “La Pantera” is one of the more tantalizing players in baseball. In 2023, he mashed 38 homers and slugged .542, which was good enough for a 129 wRC+.
The last two seasons have been a different story. He’s posted a wRC+ of 84 in both years, a farcry from his incredible 2023. Which Luis Robert Jr. will the Mets be getting? Hopefully, it will be a rejuvenated one. He’s also a plus defender in center field, which fits Stearns’ emphasis on “run prevention.”
Lastly, they finally got their ace in Peralta. While they paid a big price in top prospects Williams and Sproat, “Fastball Freddy” is the pitcher the Mets need to get over the hump in 2026. Peralta, a battle-tested pitcher, enjoyed the best season of his career last year. He posted a 2.70 ERA in 176.2 innings pitched, while also striking out 28.2% of batters faced.
Let’s not sleep on the acquisition of Myers in that deal, too. He had an excellent rookie season in 2024, when he put up a 138 ERA+ in 25 starts and mowed down the Mets in Game 3 of the Wild Card Series. He’s also under team control until 2031.
In addition to the big names, there were also some savvy moves. Luke Weaver and Luis García look to round out the bullpen. Tauchman and Melendez also interest me as depth pieces in the outfield. Tauchman, who will unfortunately miss time due to a meniscus tear, probably should have gotten a major league deal due to on-base capabilities (.356 OBP and 11.7% walk rate in 2025).
It’s also worth noting that the Metros have an entirely different coaching staff this year, outside of manager Carlos Mendoza. Mendoza kept a lot of Buck Showalter‘s staff after being hired in November 2023, so this will be the first season with his own guys. Hopefully a clean slate of coaches will make a positive impact.
Overall, the offseason was a wild few months for the Mets and their fans. While plenty of turnover occurred, the front office was able to put together what looks to be a promising squad. This offseason proves that they’re still committed to bringing a World Series trophy back to Queens.
2026 Season Preview
Projected Roster:
Lineup:
1) Francisco Lindor (SS)
2) Juan Soto (LF)
3) Bo Bichette (3B)
4) Jorge Polanco (1B)
5) Francisco Alvarez (C)
6) Brett Baty (DH)
7) Luis Robert Jr. (CF)
8) Marcus Semien (2B)
9) Carson Benge (RF)
The top third of the lineup is pretty much set in stone. Lindor is most comfortable in the leadoff spot, as evident by his 133 wRC+ since 2024, when he fully embraced that role. He is coming off a short spring due to a hamate bone fracture, but Lindor is an ironman. He’s played through injuries his entire Mets tenure, so I’m confident he’ll rebound from this well. I’m hoping to see a bounce-back year from him defensively, though. He racked up just five Outs Above Average last year, a big drop from his 2024 value of 16. His defense didn’t pass the eye test, either.
Soto and Bichette are a match made in heaven. Soto’s on-base prowess (career 18.7% walk rate) and Bichette’s knack for clutch hitting (hit .381 with RISP in 2025, best mark in MLB) should make for a lot of runs. I expect Soto to be more consistent in the second year of his mega contract, and I’m curious if he will continue stealing bases at a high rate.
The rest of lineup has some questions. Polanco should provide some thump, as the switch-hitter smashed 26 home runs while playing most of his games in the pitcher friendly confines of T-Mobile Park in Seattle. I’d like to see if Polanco can maintain his improved strike out rate.
I think Alvarez is due for a big year, as well. After getting called up from Triple-A last July, he refined his approach and found his swing. The Venezuelan had a .921 OPS down the stretch. I expect that continue while he lives up to his former prospect pedigree.
Speaking of former prospect pedigree, Baty had a quality season last year. The 2019 first-round pick was worth 3.1 fWAR in 2025, with most of his production coming in the second half once he got consistent playing time.
I envision him as the new Jeff McNeil, as the 26-year-old has picked up a number of positions in order to establish a big league role. This year, he should see time at DH, 3B, 1B, and LF. I personally think he should be the team’s starting third baseman because of his defensive capabilities, but then that would shift Bichette to DH. On a short-term contract with opt-outs, Bichette has to maximize his value. Playing in the field does that.
As I mentioned before, Robert is a mixed bag. On one hand, he has all the talent in the world. On the other, he is injury prone and has underperformed the last few years. I’m not expecting an MVP level season, but his presence raises the floor of the squad immensely. If he can put it back together just a little bit, the lineup looks better and more complete.
Similar to Robert, Semien hasn’t been amazing offensively lately. However, there is reason to believe he can bounce back. Semien slashed .270/.338/.464 from May 30 through the end of the season last year. And his OPS on the road was nearly 100 points higher than it was at Globe Life Field. He could surprise some people, but luckily for him, I don’t think he has to. If the 35-year-old can keep up his quality defense and baserunning, he’ll be a valuable player for New York.
Benge is the finishing touch to this lineup. The former Oklahoma State Cowboy (where he was teammates and roommates with McLean) was picked 19th overall in 2024 and has a high floor for a young prospect.
At just 23 years old, Benge makes contact at a high rate (80%), while also maintaining a 48% hard hit rate. I would like to see him pull more fly balls moving forward, though. He could really tap into his power potential if he can do so. Nevertheless, it is still exciting to see him make the club out of spring. He’s a great athlete with a strong arm (former pitcher in college), and is very fun to watch.
Overall, the loss of Alonso and Nimmo might hurt the power numbers for this team. However, if all goes well, this has the chance to be one best all-around lineups in baseball. Ultimately, it’s a high risk, high reward bunch, but I’m banking on the latter.
Projected Bench:
Mark Vientos (1B/3B/DH), Luis Torrens (C), Tyrone Taylor (OF), Jared Young (1B/OF)
The bench isn’t anything to write home about. Vientos had a very disappointing 2025, as his slugging percentage dropped nearly 100 points (.516 in 2024 versus .413 in 2025). It doesn’t help that he hit just .057 this spring. He still hit the ball hard, but as a negative defender, he’s quickly approaching Dom Smith and JD Davis territory. He needs results if he wants to stick around.
I enjoy Torrens as a backup catcher. He was incredible behind the plate last year, ranking in the 100th percentile in terms of Caught Stealing Above Average, per Baseball Savant. He hits the ball hard, too. The only issue is he usually beats it right into the ground (51.2% ground ball rate last year).
Taylor is an amazing defender in the outfield. He has excellent range, a great arm, and can really run. He had a rough year at the plate in 2025. The former Brewer recorded a putrid .598 OPS in 341 plate appearances. With the emergence of Robert and Benge, I forecast limited playing time for him this year.
Young’s inclusion on the roster is a surprise. The Canadian had a rough spring, but he did display some nice patience, slashing .150/.280/.300. During his brief MLB stint last season, he struck out 35% of the time. I personally thought Vidal Brujan would make the team over him, because of his versatility in the field and switch-hitting.
Projected Rotation:
1) RHP Freddy Peralta
2) LHP David Peterson
3) RHP Nolan McLean
4) RHP Clay Holmes
5) RHP Kodai Senga
If all goes well, this rotation has the potential to be really solid. Peralta is the ace this club truly needed. I have some reservations about his ability to go deep in games (5.33 IP/per game). That’s not exactly an ace-level workload, in my opinion. Regardless, he’s an instant upgrade both on and off the field.
I’m super excited to watch McLean for a full season. The game’s top pitching prospect has absolutely wicked stuff, and that was on display during his eight big league starts. The righty pitched to a 2.08 ERA, showcasing poise on the hill. He’s a legitimate Rookie of the Year contender.
The other three have question marks. Which version of Peterson will we get? Regression reared its ugly head after the All-Star break last year, and he still outperformed his expected stats (4.59 xERA). He did stay healthy throughout the season, but you could see that fatigue was setting in during the last two months of the year. An impending free agent, the 2017 first rounder is playing for his future. Will he be up for the task?
I’m interested to see how Holmes does in his second year as a starter. Strearns’ gamble on him paid off nicely in 2025, but you could tell he was being handled with kid gloves at points. That made it all the more shocking when the Mets allowed him to pitch for Team USA in the World Baseball Classic, albeit for one game. His go-to will be his bowling ball sinker (helped Holmes induce a 55.9% ground ball rate), which will pair well with Lindor and Semien up the middle, but how will Bichette and Polanco handle it at new positions? He’ll be an interesting watch this year.
Senga rounds out the rotation currently. He is a true wild card. His 2023 rookie season was awesome. The Japanese native had a 2.98 ERA and showcased his signature “ghost fork,” which allowed him to finish second in the National League Rookie of the Year race. Senga then had an injury-riddled 2024, only making one regular season start. He then followed that up with an up-and-down 2025. He looked good in Grapefruit League, though. I’m positive regarding his outlook. If he can stay healthy and consistent, he really raises the floor for this staff.
Projected Bullpen:
RHP Devin Williams, RHP Luke Weaver, LHP Brooks Raley, RHP Luis García, RHP Tobias Myers, RHP Huascar Brazobán, LHP Sean Manaea, LHP Richard “Dicky” Lovelady
This bullpen has the potential to be solid, even if it seems a little unimpressive at first glance. I’m fairly confident in a bounce-back season by Williams. His 2.68 FIP and 3.05 xERA signifies that he ran into some bad luck in 2025. Weaver is a fine set-up man. He posted a 1.05 ERA through 25.2 innings of work last season before a hamstring injury really derailed him. Weaver finished the year with a 3.62 ERA.
Raley and García, despite their age (37 and 39, respectively), should be fairly effective. The two really couldn’t be more different as pitchers. Raley, a soft tossing left, limits hard contact and walks. García, on the other hand, can still reach triple digits on his sinker and ran an elite ground ball rate of 49.7% last year. These two should fortify the late-middle innings.
Myers should be the team’s main swingman. He was particularly effective as a reliever in 2025, registering a 1.91 ERA in 28.1 innings out of the ‘pen. That looks to be the best spot for him, but I can see him starting quite a few games this season. His should be to similar to the one Trevor Williams had from 2021-2022.
The rest of the bullpen concerns me a little. Brazobán has nasty stuff and potential, but he clearly lost some steam last year after being overworked in April. If Mendoza can manage him effectively, he could be in for a nice year. That’s a big if, though. Just ask Adam Ottavino.
Manaea is a huge wild card. The Mets announced that they will use him in a “piggyback” role, meaning he will mainly log multiple innings out of the pen in relief of a starter (probably Senga). As the Mets’ highest paid pitcher, this isn’t ideal. His fastball velocity is down as the lefty didn’t crack 90 MPH during his final spring start. What can we really expect from him this year? I’m not so sure.
The final spot in the bullpen will go to Lovelady. The Mets love acquiring him and then letting him go and then acquiring him again, so I don’t believe he’ll have an extended stay in Queens. He’s nothing more than a somewhat decent lefty reliever with a fun name. He will inevitably be designated for assignment once AJ Minter returns from injury.
Other reliever prospects like Ryan Lambert and Dylan Ross interested me a lot more for this final spot, but Lovelady gets the nod due to his left-handedness and experience. We’ll probably see them up at some point this year.
Record Projections:
FanGraphs Projection: 90-72, 1st place in NL East
PECOTA Projection: 89-73, 1st place in NL East
Personal Projection: 92-70, 1st place in NL East
Myself, FanGraphs, and PECOTA all seem to be in lockstep when it comes to projecting the 2026 Mets. Both FanGraphs and PECOTA think that the Braves will bounce back from their 76-win season in 2025, but I’m not so sure about that. Jurickson Profar got popped for PEDs again, Ha-Seong Kim slipped on ice and will miss the first month of the year, and their pitching staff is in shambles. I think they stole those plays right out of the Mets’ book. The Phillies will still be good, but they didn’t really add this offseason.
From top to bottom, this team is talented enough to win the division and I think there is a world where they run away with it. I honestly think they could do better than 92 wins, if everyone reaches their full potential (Senga, Robert, Williams, etc.), but that might be a little too unrealistic. Still, for a team that appears to have some variance in terms of expected production, they feel like a high floor squad. It’s paradoxical, and yet, it works.
We have to remember one final thing. This is the Mets we’re talking about. Whatever can go wrong, will go wrong. I just hope they can keep the LOLMets antics to a minimum, but there’s really no way of knowing what could happen with this ballclub.
Final Thoughts
Personally, I’m excited for this upcoming season. While it will certainly be strange to see Alonso, Nimmo, Díaz, and McNeil suit up for other squads, I can’t wait to get to know the new guys. Ultimately, whether we like it or not, it’s a new era of Mets baseball. We can either live in the past and reminisce on old times, or we can embrace this fresh start. I know what I’ll be doing. Cheers to a great season of baseball and let’s go Mets!



